Barefoot Running: Sole Survivor

Jamie Lynn located this story about barefoot running in the the API:

Sole survivor: Missouri marathoner shuns shoes

Training goes on outside even when weather is frigid

By MARIA SUDEKUM FISHER

THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

KANSAS CITY, Mo. — When winter temperatures in the Midwest head into their single-digit death spiral, Rick Roeber goes for a run wearing tights, a turtleneck, sweat shirt, hat and gloves. But that’s all. Yes, he skips the shoes. Roeber runs barefoot and has been doing it that way since 2003. He’s logged more than 13,000 unshod miles, including about 40 marathons. (In the first, he wore flip-flops for six miles because it was 110 degrees on the Boston streets, and his soles weren’t conditioned yet.) As of Thursday, he’d put in 558 consecutive days of running barefoot; even a little Arctic air mass doesn’t stop him. Snow might, but mere frigid weather, no way. Roeber’s personal best is running outside when it was 6 degrees, but he’s had to resort to a treadmill a couple times since his streak began July 28, 2007. “I can’t go when the snow is over my ankles because then my feet just can’t warm up fast enough,” he said. “But that’s pretty much it.” The 53-year-old from Lee’s Summit started running barefoot because he was having trouble with his knees from “running stupid.” “I was very discouraged because I thought I was going to have to quit running or have my knees scoped,” he said. “And then I read how this guy was running marathons barefoot, and then learned it could help with knee problems.” Roeber tried it, liked it and built up his barefoot training to the point where he averaged about 50 miles a week in 2008. All to the benefit, he says, of his knees — and his wallet. “Running shoes give you this false sense of security,” Roeber said. “They have so much padding you think you can run as hard as you want and then they start breaking down. But smaller, quicker steps are better for your legs. “Besides, a good pair of running shoes costs $100 to $150. I could never really justify spending that kind of money.” Roeber believes running shoes encourage overstriding, which he says transfers the impact to the heel, causing “blunt force trauma up the calf and shin” and on to the knee. When runners use a shorter stride, he says, the impact is displaced evenly around the foot, allowing “very little impact to travel vertically up the leg to the knees.” But Dr. Lewis Maharam, a sports medicine specialist in New York and medical director of the ING New York City Marathon, said he is “skeptical.” “Barefoot runners show up in my office very often because they’re not getting any control (of their foot strike),” Maharam said. While occasional barefoot runs for shorter distances — about 5 miles — could help strengthen foot muscles, running shoes are designed to address biomechanical issues that most people face, Maharam said. Also, Maharam said rather than running completely barefoot he would suggest for those shorter runs wearing one of the shoe models that aims to mimic a bare foot but provides protection from cuts and scrapes. Roeber was examined for a new barefoot running study, partially financed by Vibram FiveFingers, which manufactures footwear designed to encourage the mechanics of barefooting while providing some protection. Daniel Lieberman, professor of evolutionary biology at Harvard University, is conducting the study and said while he has not yet drawn conclusions, barefoot runners do run in a “much more conservative way to avoid injury.” “People like Rick, or anybody who goes out and runs barefoot, learns that it’s kind of painful, and so you land with a much flatter foot that may have some kind of benefit. But there is a loss of absorption. “They change their gait, no question about it, and it might be in a very healthy way,” Lieberman said. “But I don’t know the answer yet.” Roeber, however, doesn’t need convincing. He says barefoot running has helped him and had a minimal effect on his race times (his fastest marathon, in shoes, is 3 hours, 16 minutes; shoeless it’s 3:35). A program manager for Sprint Nextel, Roeber thinks just about anyone could benefit some from barefooting. The streets, after all, haven’t been too hard on his feet, which he says resemble “moccasin leather,” and are “not hard as a rock.” “I’ve probably only had to pick a half-dozen pieces of glass out of them in the last five years,” he said.

*********************************************************************

SHERI’S RESPONSE:

I like seeing attention to proper running style in the news!

Your foot was made to be used, and research shows that with the advent of running shoes we are seeing more and more joint issues as the shoe does what the foot was made to do.  The foot muscles tend to atrophy, and the joints pick up the slack, which can result in pain and long term issues.

Running barefoot is not for everyone – and neither is running itself.  However, if you choose to walk/run barefoot you are going to be more careful and attentive to your movement.  That’s a good thing.  Start slow – like walking barefoot at home.  I recommend some level of foot protection when outdoors – and have not found any shoe that beats Vibram Five-Fingers in terms of minimalism and protection.  I own 4 pairs and love them.  Read our article foot dynamics here.